Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys Team

Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys is the ultimate vacation rental company that offers the highest quality service and care to clients and properties. Established in 2017 as a natural extension of the successfully established Florida Keys Real Estate Group & Duck Key Real Estate Company, we are committed to ensuring every guest's stay is happy and satisfied.

Our team of 4 property managers and quality control inspectors work tirelessly to provide the finest vacation rentals that exceed our guests' expectations.

Our team, from Left to Right

We take pride in offering quality homes, cleaned by quality employees, and providing exceptional customer and concierge service that sets us apart from the rest. Whether renting with us or entrusting your property to us as an owner, you can be confident that you are working with the best in the business. Choose Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys for an experience that will exceed your expectations.

Meet our Property Managers

Kristen Brenner - Broker/Owner & Property Manager
Kristen Brenner - Broker/Owner & Property Manager
Living and Selling the Florida Keys since 1976 Kristen graduated from Marathon High School in 1983 and earned an Interior Design BA from Washington State University in 1987. Returning to Marathon after college, she worked for a local architect, learning the construction of the Florida Keys. She started selling Real Estate at Brenner Realty in Duck Key with her parents in 1989. My first job in real estate was taking over the rental department at Brenner Realty in 1989, where I managed about 20 properties. In 1984, Kristen got her real estate license and then took over the company Duck Key Vacations and Duck Key Realty in 1999. Selling real estate in the Duck Key market, she lost her lease in the Duck Key area, and she decided to venture into the Marathon market by joining 2 different real estate offices over 7 years. After 7 years of mastering the Marathon market with those two other Real Estate companies, she ventured back on her own in 2017. Opening Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys, the Florida Keys Real Estate Group, and Reopened Duck Key Realty, 2017 to the present. Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys has 4 managers and over 220 properties. 
It is my job to exceed your expectations when it comes to property management. I have been known to respond quickly and accurately to owners and tenant concerns. I would welcome you to our Vacation Rental program!

Cell: 305-664-1453
Email: [email protected]

Team Members:
Lisa Rutkofske, Contract Coordinator
Elliott Kreizman, Customer Care
Milisa Hardin, Angela Mitchell & Jim Truemper Quality Control
Michael Scott, Handyman Extraordinaire

Team Sanderson
Bonnie & Rachel Sanderson are a mother-daughter vacation rental and real estate sales team. Bonnie has been doing rentals and sales for the last 15 years. Rachel has grown up in the business but has been active with her license for the last four years. Bonnie is originally from Hyattsville, Maryland but has lived in Marathon for 40 years. Rachel is a true conch. She was born and raised here in the Keys.  

Bonnie Sanderson
Cell: 305-393-2691
Email: [email protected]

Rachel Sanderson
Cell: 305-393-3076
Email: [email protected]

Jessenia "Jessy" Rubio
Jessenia moved to Marathon and joined Duck Key Realty in 2011 as the Office Manager. In 2013, Jessenia became a Property Manager while still managing the office. She is currently a property manager for Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys. Ms. Rubio can help you make the most of your vacation, find the right house for your stay, and help owners manage their property with the utmost professional service. Jessenia has over 12 years of customer service, management, and property care experience that serves owners and vacationers well.  

Fluent in English & Spanish
Cell: 305-731-6277
Email: [email protected]

Vicki Tashjian
Vicki Tashjian has been managing vacation rentals for about 17 years. Vicki began her career with Exit Realty and then ventured out onto her own at Florida Keys Vacations. Then, as of 2019, she joined Vacation Rentals of the Florida Keys.  

Phone: 305-393-0205
Email: [email protected]