Guest Reviews

Loved our stay! Felt like our own private island. Lots of parking space (we had four large vehicles), a large boat dock that fit our boat and jet ski, and the house was stocked with all necessities, beach chairs, beach towels, kitchen wants and needs, even a baby bath chair that came in handy. The bathrooms are updated and clean. There are two amazing coral reefs that are perfect for snorkeling only 15ish minutes by boat from the house. The view and backyard is to die for, and the house was perfect and beautiful. We really enjoyed sitting outside on the deck every morning and night. We even saw manatees right outside the dock. We hope to visit again next year!

Loved our stay! Felt like our own private island. Lots of parking space (we had four large vehicles), a large boat dock that fit our boat and jet ski, and the house was stocked with all necessities, beach chairs, beach towels, kitchen wants and needs, even a baby bath chair that came in handy. The bathrooms are updated and clean. There are two amazing coral reefs that are perfect for snorkeling only 15ish minutes by boat from the house. The view and backyard is to die for, and the house was perfect and beautiful. We really enjoyed sitting outside on the deck every morning and night. We even saw manatees right outside the dock. We hope to visit again next year!

This is our 3rs year with Jessy, she always keeps in touch and is there if we have a question within minutes ! There are so many vacation management companies to choose from, but each year we come back to Vacation Rentals of the the Florida Keys. Jessy and the rest of the staff take such good care of us and their homes, we can't imagine using any other company.

This is our 3rd stay at Castaway, as always it's impeccably clean and comfortable. We were booking for next year as we drove out of the driveway yesterday !

The house was pristine and exceeded our expectations with the expansive boat dockage, pool, ideal location and amenities within the home. The team was extremely prompt and helpful through the booking process and throughout our stay. (Thanks Vicki!!). Staying true to the namesake, we enjoyed fresh yellowtail for dinner on our final night. It was a beautiful home with everything we needed and more! Kudos to the owner and agency!

Everyone we interacted with was friendly and helpful

Loved the location

Everyone is helpful and knowlegable

Love this property. Everything you could possibly need, inside and outside.

The whole team has been very great to work with, they respond promptly and are just super nice. I have recommended your team to everyone I talk to when it comes to the Florida Keys. My first experience in the Keys was to Key Colony and I was told if its your first time to the keys you wont be disappointed with Key Colony. Ten years later it still has not disappointed. Cant wait to go back next year.

It is very well maintained property. The new addition of the Tiki Hut was such a surprise and we used it often. The Travertine tile was nice to walk on because you didnt burn your bare feet. This was the second year at this property and the 2 young grandchildren were so happy to come back to the same place. The familiarity of the property for them makes them feel at home and they were sad to leave.

Our property managers were pleasant and easy to communicate with.

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Yellowtail for Dinner and would definitely stay again.

Rachel was great!

Loved it.

Everybody was very very professional

Everything was very clean. Everything was very prompt. I would definitely stay with you again.

The house had everything you need to be comfortable just like home. Absolute perfect location.