Guest Reviews

The whole team has been very great to work with, they respond promptly and are just super nice. I have recommended your team to everyone I talk to when it comes to the Florida Keys. My first experience in the Keys was to Key Colony and I was told if its your first time to the keys you wont be disappointed with Key Colony. Ten years later it still has not disappointed. Cant wait to go back next year.

It is very well maintained property. The new addition of the Tiki Hut was such a surprise and we used it often. The Travertine tile was nice to walk on because you didnt burn your bare feet. This was the second year at this property and the 2 young grandchildren were so happy to come back to the same place. The familiarity of the property for them makes them feel at home and they were sad to leave.

Our property managers were pleasant and easy to communicate with.

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Yellowtail for Dinner and would definitely stay again.

Rachel was great!

Loved it.

Everybody was very very professional

Everything was very clean. Everything was very prompt. I would definitely stay with you again.

The house had everything you need to be comfortable just like home. Absolute perfect location.

They were wonderful, especially Jessy.

Awesome!

Very helpful and knowledgeable.

Was a perfect location for us. We enjoyed all of the properties amenities and the boat docking. Thank you for a very enjoyable week.

Elliott was great, answered questions & texts promptly and knowledgeably.

We had a great time, thanks!

The realty team was very friendly and easy to work with. It was my first experience of renting a vacation property and it was as great as I had hoped. I would rent this again.

Overall, it was a great place to stay for our family vacation. The pool was beautiful and it was nice being on a canal to see manatees swimming about! I would recommend this place to anyone wanting a quiet relaxing vacation home to enjoy but still close enough to the liveliness of Key West.

Kristen and the team were amazing

Wonderful property! We have stayed at many 5 star resorts and this property out did them all.

Everything was perfect. The house was very clean. We had everything we needed from extra pillows to beach chairs. The property manager responded promptly to our needs. Check in and check out was a breeze. We enjoyed our stay and will definitely return.

Friendly, courteous, and knowledgable.

Amazing experience. Can't wait to stay again next year.

Kristin and her team were very helpful

The property is beautiful! We had a fantastic view of the sunset from the second floor patio. The home is tastefully decorated and homey. Key colony has restaurants within the community The cabana club was great to stop by for a quick drink/snack or a dip at the pool. Right outside the development was a great restaurant right on the water, a public boat ramp, and gas station. We will definitely be returning!

Very helpful. Nice welcome basket provided everything needed to start our vacation.

We have loved this property since our first visit to Casa Clara in 2016. We started staying in Keys Please in 2019 and its now our favorite and we look forward to returning in 2024.

We had a wonderful stay, perfect property for families and boating. The house was beautiful. Great location for boating to Sombrero Reef and fishing and then cooling off after in the pool. We saw lots of manatees in the canal and had a great vacation!